The annual Fortnitemares event has become a cornerstone of the Fortnite calendar, a digital masquerade where the line between the island’s chaos and the spirit of Halloween blurs like ink in water. Since 2017, Epic Games has transformed the battle royale into a playground of nightmarish delights, layering each October with Cube Monsters, ghostly quests, and a parade of skins that stitch pop culture’s darkest figures into the game’s ever-expanding tapestry. By 2026, the wishlist for new Fortnitemares skins has grown into a thriving archive of fan cravings, a patchwork quilt sewn from the fabric of nightmares old and new. As another Halloween approaches, here are ten horror icons the community still dreams of seeing descend upon the island.
Buffy Summers
A slayer who turned graveyards into gymnasiums, Buffy Summers would bring a perfect blend of athleticism and wit to Fortnitemares. Her universe shares the event’s irreverent heartbeat—monster battles served with a side of snark. Many believe Buffy, in her leather jacket and crossbow, would glide through Cube Monster hordes like a silver needle through dark fabric. Spike, with his platinum hair and vampire swagger, would follow as a natural counterpart, offering players a chance to inhabit both sides of the crypt.
Jason Voorhees
Few absences haunt the Fortnite rumor mill more persistently than Jason Voorhees. The hulking figure from Crystal Lake, forever frozen behind a hockey mask, represents a missing puzzle piece in Epic’s horror mosaic. His silent, supernatural presence makes any final circle feel like a campfire story whispered for years, his machete never quite breaching the island’s shore. With Michael Myers and Leatherface already stalking the landscape, adding Jason feels less like a crossover and more like an inevitability delayed.
Fox Mulder and Dana Scully
The truth is out there—and so are the Cube Monsters. Agents Mulder and Scully from The X-Files would arrive as a bundled duo, turning every anomaly into an X-File. In a Fortnitemares landscape thick with paranormal fog, these FBI experts would feel like anchors of skepticism in a world gone mad. Their flashlights and trench coats could be more than cosmetic; they’d symbolize the human inquiry scratching at the edges of Fortnite’s conspiracies.
Carrie White
Carrie’s prom night massacre has bloomed anew in the public imagination, making the telekinetic teen a favorite for a Fortnitemares debut. Her blood-soaked gown and wide-eyed stare would turn any skirmish into a revenge fantasy. Unlike the island’s usual warriors, Carrie’s power whispers of a quiet storm—a girl whose trauma erupts in a swirl of levitating debris, a fitting addition to a realm already crawling with ghouls.
Pyramid Head
From the rust-laced corridors of Silent Hill, Pyramid Head lumbers into the wishlist with a great blade that looks heavy enough to split the sky. His mute menace and blood-stained apron make him a terror that transcends genre. In the hands of a Fortnite player, he would turn squad rushes into psychological horror. With the Silent Hill 2 remake rekindling the franchise, 2026 is the perfect year for this executioner to descend upon the island.
The Sanderson Sisters
Winifred, Mary, and Sarah Sanderson swooped back into relevance with Hocus Pocus 2, and their comedic wickedness makes them a natural fit for Fortnitemares. Imagining the three witches cackling across the map on their brooms is like watching a Halloween parade invade a battlefield. Their distinct personalities—bossy, goofy, and flirty—would offer a trio of skins that transform squads into a coven.
Pearl
The smiling, axe-wielding Pearl from the modern slasher canon would inject a layer of unsettling charm into Fortnitemares. Her permanent, unnerving grin—freeze-framed from the film’s credits—would become a symbol of manic determination in build fights. Watching this obsessed farmer’s wife chase down opponents with a pitchfork is a nightmare made mobile, and one that fits snugly into the event’s grab bag of frights.
Betelgeuse
Say his name three times, and Betelgeuse might just materialize in the Item Shop. The bio-exorcist’s chaotic energy matches Fortnite’s penchant for the bizarre, like a poltergeist released from a props closet. A skin could unlock a cascade of tie-in cosmetics: Lydia Deetz’s gothic dresses, the shrunken head Bob, and even an emote that recreates the “Day-O” dinner possession.
Freddy Fazbear
Five Nights at Freddy’s has clawed its way from indie horror to a multimedia juggernaut, making Freddy Fazbear a top-tier request. The animatronic bear and his band—Bonnie, Chica, and Springtrap—would transform any match into a haunted pizzeria. For a generation that grew up watching these metallic monsters on Let’s Play channels, seeing them lumber through Pleasant Park would be a dream (or nightmare) realized.
Clickers
The fungal horrors from The Last of Us offer a grotesque aesthetic that Fortnitemares can amplify with glowing Cube Monster effects. A Clicker skin, with its split-open face and erratic movements, would bring a visceral unease to the island. Ellie and Joel might be safer, PEGI-friendly alternatives, but the true fright lies in those shambling bodies that were once human—a reminder that even in Fortnite, evolution can take monstrous turns.
Fortnitemares has always thrived on the tension between playful chaos and genuine creepiness. These ten additions each represent a different shade of horror, from campy witches to silent executioners, and their inclusion would thread new nightmares into an ever-expanding tapestry of fear. As Epic Games continues to fling open the doors of the metaverse, the community’s collective speculation becomes a séance of its own—summoning icons from screens across decades into the one realm where they can all build, shoot, and haunt side by side.